South African Cast Iron Legends
Cast Iron Legends: Falkirk vs. Best Duty
South Africa boasts a rich tradition of outdoor cooking, and at the heart of it lies the potjiekos, a slow-cooked stew simmered in a cast iron pot over an open fire. Two South African manufacturers have been instrumental in shaping this tradition: Falkirk and Best Duty. Let’s delve into their histories and compare the quality of their iconic cast iron pots.
Falkirk: A Pioneering Legacy
The Falkirk story begins in the 19th century with the Durban Falkirk Iron Company. They are credited with being the first local manufacturer of the potjie pot, forever changing the South African culinary landscape. Their pots were renowned for their exceptional quality – thick, heavy cast iron that retained heat beautifully, perfect for slow-cooking. Falkirk’s popularity soared, with waiting lists stretching to 18 months! Sadly, the company faced financial difficulties and closed its doors in the early 1990s.
Best Duty: Carrying the Torch
Established in 1984, Best Duty took over the mantle of cast iron pot production in South Africa. They remain a leading manufacturer, known for their commitment to quality and upholding the South African potjiekos tradition. Best Duty offers a variety of cast iron cookware, including oil-cured and enamel-coated potjies.
Comparing Quality: Vintage Charm vs. Modern Functionality
Since Falkirk pots are no longer in production, comparing them directly to Best Duty’s offerings is a bit tricky. However, we can explore the characteristics of each brand:
- Falkirk: Vintage Falkirk pots are prized by collectors for their exceptional heat retention and durability. They are often thicker than their modern counterparts. However, due to their age, some may require restoration or seasoning.
- Best Duty: Best Duty pots cater to the modern cook. They come pre-seasoned and are generally lighter than vintage Falkirk pots, making them easier to handle. Best Duty also offers a wider variety of sizes and styles to suit different cooking needs.
The Final Verdict: A Matter of Preference
Ultimately, the choice between a vintage Falkirk or a modern Best Duty pot comes down to personal preference.
- For the traditionalist: If you value the historical significance and potentially superior heat retention, a vintage Falkirk pot might be the perfect match. Be prepared to invest some time in restoration or seasoning.
- For the modern cook: If you prioritize convenience and a wider selection, a Best Duty pot offers excellent quality and functionality.
Whichever brand you choose, you’ll be inheriting a piece of South African culinary history, perfect for creating delicious potjiekos for generations to come.
